Page 1 of 1

Promotion of Major General or Admiral Rick Hunter and the Role of Standardized Testing

Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2025 2:48 am
by Mecha8
Now and then, people like to say that Rick suddenly jumped the ranks to become Major General or Admiral because there was no one else. It’s a possible diss against what he had done as Skull Leader during the First Robotech War and after Dolza’s attack of Earth, and the novels mention the planning he had done side-by-side with Lisa during the period after Dolza’s Rain.

But I want to ask, what role do you think that standardized testing played, if any, in his promotion? This question applies to whether going by the Sentinels video in which he’s already Major General before the launch of the SDF-3 or going by the novels and Sentinels comics in which he’s Admiral before the SDF-3 launch (though the animated series establishes him as Admiral during the Third Robotech War). I find it hard to believe that no written test was given to Rick before his jump in promotion. And even if the higher-ups pretty much made up their mind to give him this vast promotion no matter what, I’d think they’d be curious to see how well he would do in standardized testing. Perhaps I’m looking at my own experience with standardized testing when it applies to other things, say, gaining a teacher certification, so I’m interested in what those in the military have to say about this question, though anyone can answer since it is a piece of fiction at the center of what we’re talking about.

Hope no one minds that this topic overlaps with the novels and comics, but the question originates with the animation itself, and I think any answer applies to all three—animation, comic books, and novels. Roleplaying game, too.

Re: Promotion of Major General or Admiral Rick Hunter and the Role of Standardized Testing

Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2025 8:49 pm
by Andrew Knyte
Hey! It's a very interesting question and it would be interesting to see how those with a military background would answer it.

I also wonder who would have been in charge of appointing Rick to the role.

The Battlestar Galactica reboot series (one of my favorite TV shows of all time) featured similar promotions. Commander Adama becomes Admiral after a death of a previous Admiral, and his son gets promoted from Captain to Commander as a result of the same death. And another character gets promoted to XO after the previous one left the fleet temporarily.

So I'm not sure standardized tests beyond the entry point into the service would have played much of a role. Strictly my opinion, of course.

Re: Promotion of Major General or Admiral Rick Hunter and the Role of Standardized Testing

Posted: Sun Nov 30, 2025 5:14 pm
by Mecha8
I haven’t watched the Battlestar Galactica reboot in a while, but I think the instances you mentioned were battlefield promotions, in other words, promotions that occur for servicemen while deployed in combat so that suddenly vacant positions are filled. Whether stated or not in the lore, I think battlefield promotions happened all of the time in Robotech, particularly during the Macross Saga. When Roy perishes, they soon make Rick the leader of Skull, which feels like a promotion, though his rank might not have been changed at the same time. From a purist POV for the animation, Rick is a Major General in the Sentinels video, but many more years pass between events in that video and the Invid Invasion story of the Robotech show when compared to other sources. So I think it’s possible that Rick might have had a couple battlefield promotions in order to be Admiral in the third saga of the TV series, going strictly by the animation.

Check out my attached screenshot with collected excerpts from a study and analysis of the use of standardized testing in the U.S. military branches — a Rand Corporation document released in 2012. I discovered it well after my original post. Referring to the right-side column of text and once again going only by the animation, it seems possible that Rick entered a graduate program in order to be considered for the rank of Major General, and with further education often comes standardized testing required by such a program.

If we go by other sources outside of the animation (yeah, the novels), Rick definitely would not have enrolled in any further education program since he wasn’t interested in being more than a pilot after the destruction of SDFs 1 and 2 and New Macross. Referring to the left side of text this time, particularly the Navy part, it appears that Rick probably had taken some standardized testing as part of his requirements to join aviation within the Robotech Defense Force aboard the SDF-1 and not end up with some other role. (The fortress certainly must have had an accelerated program for mecha pilots since the brass were drawing heavily from the civilian pool as the SDF-1 faced constant combat with the Zentraedi.) But going by what appears to be a long-used model within the U.S. Navy, with some adjustments made for the story being told in the novel series, Rick’s pre-SDF-3 promotion to Vice Admiral would have relied beforehand on reviews of his record by higher-ups. So, yeah, no standardized testing required at this stage of his career if going by the novels.

Andrew, as for military officers who would have been in on Rick’s promotion, there’s Lisa, Reinhardt (who is in the animation and the novels), and other high-ranking officers, though nameless. It’s hard to believe that Maistroff and Caruthers (the latter named in the novels), both in the Macross Saga portion of the animation, wouldn’t have played a part in promoting Rick.

And as Andrew said, maybe some fellow members with actual military experience could share their thoughts on this topic, though anyone is welcome. I mean, look at how much my non-vet self wrote about it!